Just Some of the advantages of
using Waterjets...


A shop
without a waterjet is like a carpenter without a hammer - Sure you can
use the back end of a screwdriver to drive in nails, but once you have
the hammer, why would you ever use the screwdriver to hammer in
nails?
The screwdriver still has its place, but so does the hammer.
"If you need a
machine and don't buy it,
then you will ultimately find you have
paid for it but don't have it" - Henry Ford.
Above: machine any
2D shape with 1 tool. Slots, radii, holes, and
profile in one 2 minute setup!
I
see it happen all the time: Joe Machine Shop Owner has been
looking at waterjets for 3 years, but just can't seem to make the
"spooky decision" to buy a waterjet. Finally, he gets a contract
to make 20,000 of some weird and difficult part that only a waterjet
can do. He buys it to "solve a problem - he buys the machine for
this one big job. A month after the machine is installed, he
isn't even using it for the "special
application" that he bought it for. Why? Because he is too
busy
using it do do all sorts of "normal" machining that he took from his
other
machines! Now that he knows what the machine can do, he has also
got
a bunch of new work from his customers. He has found that it is
way
easier to use for many parts he was making on his mills / laser / EDM,
punch, etc.
And he has found that he can enhance his other machining processes by
doing
part of the machining on the waterjet...
(I
keep thinking of all the people who used to say, "What would I ever
need a computer for?".)
Here
are some of the benefits to using a waterjet:
- Cheaper
than other processes.
- Cut
virtually any material:
- pre
hardened steel
- mild
steel
- exotics
like Titanium, Inconel, Hastalloy
- gummy
304 stainless
- (most
steels cut at the same speed, whether hardened, or not.)
- Copper,
Brass, Aluminum: They are a cinch!
- brittle
materials like glass, ceramic, quartz, stone.
- laminates
- flammable
materials
- Cut
thin stuff, or thick stuff
- Make
all sorts of shapes with only one tool.
- Cut
wide range of thickness’ to reasonable tolerance up to 2” (50mm) thick
- Up
to 5” (127mm) or thicker where tolerance not important, or in soft
materials.
- No
Heat Generated / No heat affected zones - this is cold cutting!
- No
mechanical stresses
- Cut
virtually any shape:
- Fast
Setup:
- Only
one tool to qualify / No tool changes required
- Fast
turn around on the machine. Make a part, then 2 minutes be
making a completely different part from a completely different material.
- Leaves
a satin smooth finish, thus reducing secondary operations
- Clean
cutting process without gasses or oils
- Makes
its own start holes
- Narrow
kerf removes only a small amount of material.
- Your
"scrap" metal is easier to recycle or re-use (no oily chips!)
- Modern
systems are now very easy to learn.
- You
can trade off tolerance vs speed from feature to feature on your part.
- Can
easily switch between high production, and single piece production, on
the same machine, with no extra effort.
- Are
very safe. (No, they don't explode, thanks to the nearly
incompressible property of water.)
- Draw
the part / cut the part. It is that easy! Everyone in your
shop can learn to use it quickly.
- No
"scaley"
edges, which makes it easier to make a high quality weld
- Machine
composite materials, or materials where dissimilar materials are glued
together
- Machine stacks
of thin parts all at once.
Above: Get nice edge
quality from funky materials.
When
comparing with Lasers:
- Abrasive
waterjets can machine
many materials that lasers cannot. (Reflective materials in particular,
such as Aluminum and Copper.
- Uniformity
of material is not
very important to an Abrasivejet.
- Abrasive
jets do not heat your
part. Thus there is no thermal distortion or hardening of the
material.
- Precision
abrasive jet machines
can obtain about the same or higher tolerances than lasers (especially
as thickness increases).
- Your
capital equipment costs for
water jet are generally much lower than that for a laser. I.e. for the
price of a laser, you can purchase several abrasivejet-machining
centers.
- Abrasive
jets can machine thicker
materials. How thick you can cut is
a function of how long you are willing to wait. 2" (50mm) steel and 3"
(76mm) aluminum is quite common. I heard of people doing up to 10"
(250mm) steel, and 24" (600mm) thick
glass with high horsepower systems. Once you get over 2" (50mm) thick
it is very
difficult to get precision, however. Lasers seem to have a maximum of
0.5" (12mm)
- 0.75" (19mm).
- Abrasive
jets are safer. No burnt
fingers, no noxious fumes, and no fires. (You still have to keep those
fingers out of the beam.)
- Abrasive
jets are more
environmentally friendly.
- Maintenance
on the abrasive jet
nozzle is simpler than that of a laser,
though probably just as frequent.
- Abrasive
jets are capable of
similar tolerances on thin parts, and better on parts thicker than .5"
- Abrasive
jets do not loose much
"focus" when cutting over uneven surfaces.
- While
lasers are often faster on
thinner materials...
- ...it
may be cheaper and faster to simply buy two or three abrasive jet
machining centers to do the same work
- ...you
can stack materials, so you are cutting multiple thin parts
simultaneously.
- ...you can run
additional cutting heads in parallel on a single machine
- Modern
Abrasive jets are typically much easier to operate and maintain than
lasers, which means that every employee in your shop can be quickly
trained
to run one!
- Abrasivejets
don't create "scaley" edges, which makes it easier to make a high
quality weld
- Many shops that
have lasers also have waterjets, as they are complimentary tools.
Where
one leaves off, the other picks up.
Above: Much faster
than EDM! If you have an EDM, then you
definitely
have a need for a waterjet!
When
comparing with EDM:
- Abrasive
jets are much faster
than EDM.
- Abrasive
Jets machine a wider
variety of materials (virtually any material).
- Uniformity
of material is not
very important to an Abrasivejet.
- Abrasive
jets make their own
pierce holes.
- Abrasive
jets do not heat the
surface of what they machine.
- Abrasive
jets are capable of
ignoring material aberrations that would
cause wire EDM to lose flushing.
- Abrasive
Jet machining is useful
for creating start holes for wire insertion later on. (a mill could do
the job, but only after spotting the hole, changing tools to drill a
pilot, then changing tools again to drill out the hole).
- New
technology allows Abrasive
jets to obtain tolerances of up to +/-.003" (0.075mm) or better (I have
personally done some +/-.001" (0.025mm) work, but that's the exception,
not the norm, and only on certain shapes and materials.)
- No
heat affected Zone with
Abrasive jets.
- Abrasive
jets require less setup.
- Make
bigger parts.
- Many EDM shops are also buying
waterjets. Waterjets can be considered
to be like super-fast EDM machines with less precision. This
means
that many parts of the same catagory that an EDM would do can be done
faster
and cheaper on an abrasivejet, if the tolerances are not extreme.
Above: Wire EDM fixturing in an abrasivejet machining
center.
This makes precision fixturing possible. It also allows for
pre-machining on the abrasive jet to release stresses in the material,
and then use the exact same fixturing on the EDM to do secondary
operations and final cutting to extreme tolerance.
Wow, that is a thin
cut!
When
comparing with Plasma / Fine Plasma:
- Abrasivejets
provide a nicer edge
finish
- Abrasivejets
don't heat the part
- Abrasivejets
can cut virtually
any material
- Abrasivejets
are more precise
- Plasma
is typically faster
- Waterjets would make a great
compliment to a plasma shop where more precision
or higher quality is required, or for parts where heating is not good,
or
where there is a need to cut a wider range of materials.
Above: (Many) Modern
machines are relatively clean and quiet.
When
comparing with Flame cutting:
- Abrasivejets
provide a much nicer
edge finish
- Abrasivejets
don't heat the part
- Abrasivejets
can cut virtually
any material
- Abrasivejets
are more precise
- Flame
cutting is typically faster
- Flame
cutting is typically
cheaper, if you can use it.
- Waterjets would make a great
compliment to a flame cutting where more precision
or higher quality is required, or for parts where heating is not good,
or where there is a need to cut a wider range of materials.
Above: Do
pre-machining, and save your other tools from having to do so
much
work!
When
comparing with milling:
- There
is only one tool to qualify
on an abrasivejet
- Setup
and Fixturing typically
involves placing the material on the table with an abrasivejet
- Cleanup
is much faster with an
abrasivejet
- Programming
is easier and faster
- Machine
virtually any material,
including:
- brittle
materials
- pre
hardened materials
- otherwise
difficult materials
such as Titanium, Hastalloy, Inconel, SS 304, hardened tool steel....
- Waterjets are used a lot for
complimenting or replacing milling operations.
They are used for roughing
out parts prior to milling, for replacing milling entirely, or for
providing secondary machining on parts that just came off the mill.
For this reason, many
traditional machine shops are adding waterjet capability to provide a
competitive edge.
When
comparing with Punch Press
- Lower
cost per piece for short
runs
- Place
holes closer to the
materials edge
- Fast
turn-around
- Minimal
setup
- Thick
materials are fine
- Brittle
materials are no problem.
- Hard
materials are easy.
- Some stamping houses are using
waterjets for fast turn-around, or for low
quantity / prototyping work. Waterjets make a
great
complimentary tool for punch presses and
the like because they offer a wider range of capability for similar
parts.
For high production of thin sheet-metal, the stamp will be more p
rofitable in many cases, but for
short runs, difficult material, thick material, and many other similar
but different applications, waterjets have their place.
Above: About 5
minutes is all it took to make this custom file!
That is
some very hard material! Consider hardening the metal before you
cut it.
Abrasivejets
also play a big part as just one part in a larger manufacturing
process. For example, abrasivejets are often used to machine
features into an existing part, or to do pre-machining to remove
material before precision finishing on other machinery.


This article last
reviewed / updated 5/4/2008 by Carl olsen
**
Many of the pictures on this page are
courtesy of OMAX Corporation, which
is a company that makes complete waterjet
machining
centers, and is where the author works.
Copyright © 1994-2008
Olsen Software, LLC